motorcycle tail bags vs. saddle bags:

motorcycle tail Bags vs. saddle bags: which one is right for you?

when it comes to motorcycle luggage, two of the most popular options are tail bags and saddle bags. choosing the right one depends on your riding style, storage needs, and personal preferences. In this blog, we’ll compare tail bags and saddle bags, highlighting their pros and cons, and provide examples of five top-performing options for each type.

Tail bags

Tail bags are mounted on the rear seat or luggage rack of a motorcycle. They are often compact and versatile, catering to riders who need quick storage solutions for shorter trips.

Pros of Tail bags:

• Compact and Portable: Tail bags are smaller and lighter, making them easy to carry off the bike.

• No Interference with Rider’s Legs: Mounted on the back of the bike, they don’t get in the way of the rider’s movement.

• Easy Installation: Most tail bags come with straps, bungee cords, or quick-release systems for effortless attachment and removal.

• Aerodynamics: Tail bags typically have a streamlined shape that reduces wind resistance.

• Ideal for Short Trips: Perfect for carrying essentials like a rain jacket, water bottle, or tools.

Cons of Tail bags:

• Limited Storage Capacity: Tail bags generally offer less storage compared to saddle bags.

• Single Mounting Point: If not secured properly, they can shift during rides.

• Less Versatile for Touring: Not ideal for riders who need to carry a lot of gear for extended trips.

Top 5 Motorcycle Tail Bags:

• Nelson-Rigg Commuter Tail Bag: Offers a durable design with expandable storage, perfect for daily commuters.

• Kriega US-20 Drypack: Known for being waterproof and versatile, this bag is great for any weather.

• Givi EA122 Tail Bag: Sleek and sporty, it’s a compact solution with ample compartments.

• Oxford OL310 Tail Bag: Offers a budget-friendly yet robust design with expandable capacity.

• Dainese D-Tail Motorcycle Bag: A premium option with an aerodynamic profile and high-quality materials.

Saddle Bags

Saddle bags, also known as panniers, hang on either side of the motorcycle, typically over or near the rear wheel. They are ideal for riders who need more storage space for longer journeys.

Pros of Saddle Bags:

• Ample Storage Space: Saddle bags provide significantly more storage than tail bags, making them ideal for touring.

• Better Weight Distribution: Since they are mounted on both sides, saddle bags help maintain balance by distributing weight evenly.

• Weatherproof Options: Many saddle bags come with waterproof materials or rain covers for all-weather riding.

• Variety of Styles: Available in hard and soft options to suit different aesthetics and functional needs.

• Permanent Mounting Options: Hard saddle bags can be mounted permanently, offering convenience for frequent travelers.

Cons of Saddle Bags:

• Bulky Design: They can make the motorcycle wider, which may be inconvenient for city riding or lane splitting.

• Installation Complexity: Some saddle bags require specific mounting hardware, making installation more involved.

• Cost: High-quality hard saddle bags can be expensive compared to tail bags.

• Leg Interference Risk: Depending on the design, they may slightly limit leg movement when mounting or dismounting.

Top 5 Motorcycle Saddle Bags:

• Viking Bags Lamellar Hard Saddlebags: Durable and sleek, perfect for cruisers and touring motorcycles.

• Givi Trekker Outback Saddle Bags: Made of aluminum, they’re ideal for adventure touring and rugged conditions.

• Saddlemen Drifter Saddlebags: Classic leather-look bags with a timeless aesthetic and spacious compartments.

• Nelson-Rigg Sierra Dry Saddlebags: Soft, lightweight, and 100% waterproof, great for sport or adventure bikes.

• Harley-Davidson Hard Saddlebags: A premium option designed specifically for Harley-Davidson bikes, offering top-tier quality and fitment.

Tail Bags vs. Saddle Bags: A Quick Comparison

Tail Bags

Saddle Bags

Storage Capacity

Limited

Ample

Installation

Easy

More complex

Ideal For

Short trips, commuters

Long-distance touring

Cost

Generally affordable

Can be expensive

Aesthetic

Sleek and compact

Bulkier, more options

Space Occupancy

No leg interference

May restrict leg movement

Which One Should You Choose?

• Go for a tail bag if you’re a commuter, weekend rider, or need a lightweight and portable solution for short trips.

• Opt for saddle bags if you’re a touring enthusiast or need ample storage for multi-day trips.

GoodGearHub wrap up

The author has used both and contrary to popular opinion he prefers tail bags. The answer is simple - no fuss packing just use packing cubes and fill it. Installation and uninstallation using luggage straps is a matter of seconds. Saddle bags on the other hand as they grow in capacity is a herculean task to take off and carry unless you are using very high end saddle bags. Also the width of the motorcycle increases a lot with saddle bags. Having said this please pick your own preferences. The author finally chose the sw motech tail bag five years ago after a dozen other types so bags and it works for him. Lastly as he rides solo he can afford to use a tail bag not all can so choose wisely…